There are two main types of surgery recommended by the surgical team. Gastric Sleeve and Gastric bypass. There is also a Mini Gastric Bypass procedure, but we do not compare it here. Let’s look at the differences.
A gastric sleeve is a surgical procedure that removes up to 80-85% of the stomach pouch. Less volume of food can be consumed in one sitting and as a result, the patient;
The gastric sleeve is not reversible but a
majority of patients report only positive
outcomes and they have no regrets,
especially given the new life being
embarked on. Is usually recommended
for patients with a BMI of under 45.
Gastric bypass is exactly how it sounds. The procedure creates a new stomach pouch and reroutes the intestine bypassing the stomach. As a result, the patient;
The gastric bypass is a reversible procedure (under the right circumstances) given that the stomach is left intact but a large portion is bypassed. The bypass procedure is usually reserved for patients with a BMI of over 45.Read more
|Gastric sleeve overview||Gastric bypass|
|Method of loss||Restriction method (less food)||Combines restriction (less food) with malabsorption|
|Procedure||Surgeon removes 80% of the stomach and creates a tube-like shaped stomach (sleeve) using titanium staples||Surgeon divides the stomach into a small upper pouch and large lower pouch and attached to the small intestine.|
|Surgery method||Laparoscopic (keyhole) Minimally Invasive Surgery||Laparoscopic (keyhole) or Minilap (large incision)|
|Hospital stay||2-3 days in hospital - minimum 5-7 days from surgery before cleared to fly||2-3 days in hospital - minimum 5-7 days from surgery before cleared to fly|
|RECOVERY||Normal activity within 6 weeks||Normal activity within 6 weeks|
|Pain||Manageable - Pain scale 3-4 for 1st 3 days (person dependent)||Manageable - Pain scale 3-4 for 1st 3 days (person dependent)|
|Time off work||1-3 weeks (depending on occupation)||1-3 weeks (depending on occupation)|
|Risks short term||
|Weight loss month 1||Typically lose 2.5 to 7kg per week||Typically lose 2.5 to 7kg per week|
|Weight loss month 3||33% of excess body weight or 29kg||33% of excess body weight or 29kg|
|Weight loss month 6||50% excess body weight or 44kg||50% excess body weight or 44kg|
|Weight loss month 12||70% excess body weight or 62kg||65% body weight or 57kg|
When we say 50% of excess body weight, we mean the difference between what you
weigh NOW and the top of your healthy BMI range. For the examples in the table
above we used a 170cm, 160kg individual whose top healthy body weight should be
72kg. The loss required to get into the healthy range is 88kg. These types of losses
are indicative of the AVERAGE losses, some people lose less, some people much,
Both patients had the same amount of stomach pouch removed, both patients hunger
hormones are muted and both patients can eat the same volume. Typically the person
who sticks to the plan provided to the patient is the one who will exceed the average
results and the person who goes outside of the recommendations may not achieve the
same results in the same amount of time.
If you experience no loss at all, it has nothing to do with the surgery and has
everything to do with what is happening with caloric intake. Generally with 80-85% of
the stomach removed the maximum caloric intake will be around 1000 (it is near
impossible to eat any more than this). Anyone who only eats 1000 calories per day
WILL lose weight. This is not an opinion, this is a fact of science.
Everybody requires a minimum number of calories to live. This minimum number is
called the basal metabolic rate (BMR). Your BMR is the number of calories your organs
need to function while you perform no activity whatsoever. Think about sitting in front
of the couch all day without moving.
So for the female in this example, the deficit if you eat 1000 calories is 887 calories per
day and the male is 1399 calories per day. This will then be the energy the body will
draw from your fat stores to power itself.
If you ‘drink’ your calories (there are many creative ways some people will still do this)
you can end up consuming more calories per day than you did pre-surgery and of
course, you will not lose weight! Someone who drinks 6 thick shakes, a few bottles of
wine or a melted tub of ice cream will not experience loss. Usually, people who drink
their calories have underlying issues that need to be resolved in conjunction with
surgery. 99% of people who have this surgery fully use the tool that has been provided
and gets their lives on track.
A lot of patients wrestle with the choice of the sleeve or bypass. Once we submit
your details to the surgeon, he will make recommendations based on your personal
circumstances. See more detailed information about each procedure:
Don’t procrastinate and lose months or years! Chat to us online or click the button
below to complete the assessment. If you would prefer a phone consult, please use
the form on this page and we will contact you at a convenient time.